The Cake Lady Cottage is officially open!! Please check our Facebook page for up to date hours and days open!
Our Premium Cakes
Click here to see our other cake options
Sizes & Pricing
Sheet cakes are scored 2x2x4 serving size. All sheet cakes come scored for easy cutting unless otherwise requested. For wedding size servings/ smaller servings each piece can be cut into 2. This line of cakes is not customizable. A special message can be added on top.

$40
6" Round
(serves 8-12)
$55
8" Round
(serves 12-18)
$75
10" Round
(serves 20-40)
$70 ($2.92/serving)
Small Sheet(9x13)
(serves 24-48)
$96 ($2.74/serving)
Medium Sheet(11x15)
(serves 35-70)
$162 ($3/serving)
Large Sheet(12x18)
(serves 54-108)
Premium Flavors
White with Custard
Layers of moist white cake filled with vanilla custard. Frosted in white buttercream. Garnished with diamond sprinkles.
Raspberry/Lemon Creme
Layers of moist white cake filled with lemon custard and raspberry fruit filling. Frosted in whipped cream cheese frosting. Garnished with fresh raspberries and lemons.
Lemon Creme
Layers of moist white cake filled with lemon custard. Frosted in whipped cream cheese frosting. Garnished with fresh lemon slices.
Lemon/Blueberry Creme
Layers of moist white cake with fresh blueberries filled with lemon custard. Frosted in whipped cream cheese frosting. Garnished with fresh lemon and blueberry.
Raspberry Cream Cheese
Layers of moist vanilla cake filled with raspberry fruit filling and whipped cream cheese. Frosted in whipped cream cheese frosting. Garnished with fresh raspberries.
Strawberry Cream Cheese
Layers of moist vanilla cake filled with strawberry fruit filling and whipped cream cheese. Frosted in whipped cream cheese frosting. Garnished with fresh strawberry slices.
NEW! Blueberry Muffin
Layers of moist fresh blueberry cake filled with vanilla buttercream. Frosted in vanilla buttercream. Garnished with fresh blueberries.
NEW! Strawberry Shortcake
Layers of moist white cake filled with whipped cream and chopped fresh strawberries. Frosted in whipped cream frosting. Garnished with fresh chopped strawberries.
NEW! White Chocolate Peanut Butter
Layers of moist vanilla cake filled with whipped peanut butter filling. Frosted in vanilla buttercream. Garnished with white chocolate reeses and white chocolate drizzle.
Coconut
Layers of moist white cake filled with coconut custard. Frosted in white buttercream. Garnished with coconut flakes.
UPDATED! Mixed Berry
Layers of moist white cake filled with vanilla custard and fresh chopped berries. Frosted in whipped cream frosting. Garnished with fresh seasonal berries.
Oreo
Layers of moist oreo crumble cake filled with buttercream frosting and oreo crumbles. Frosted in white buttercream. Garnished with oreo crumbles.
NEW! Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Layers of moist vanilla cake filled with cookie dough and chocolate chips. Frosted in vanilla buttercream. Garnished with edible cookie dough, chocolate chips, and cookie pieces.
NEW! Biscoff Cookie Butter
Layers of moist Biscoff cookie butter cake filled with Cookie butter buttercream and Biscoff butter. Frosted in cookie butter buttercream. Garnished with Biscoff cookies and Biscoff butter drip.
Half & Half
Bottom two layers are moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate custard. Top two layers are moist white cake with vanilla custard. Frosted in white buttercream frosting.
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Layers of moist chocolate cake filled with whipped peanut butter filling. Frosted in chocolate buttercream. Garnished with Reese cups and chocolate drizzle.
Turtle
Layers of moist chocolate cake filled with caramel. Frosted in chocolate buttercream. Garnished with toasted pecans. Drizzled with chocolate and caramel.
Chocolate Raspberry
Layers of moist chocolate cake filled with raspberry fruit filling. Frosted in chocolate buttercream. Garnished with fresh raspberries and chocolate drizzle.
NEW! Chocolate Strawberry Shortcake
Layers of moist chocolate cake filled with whipped cream and fresh strawberries. Frosted in whipped cream. Garnished with fresh strawberries and chocolate pieces.
Chocolate with Chocolate Custard
Layers of moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate custard. Frosted in chocolate buttercream. Garnished with chocolate pieces and chocolate drizzle.
German Chocolate
Layers of moist chocolate cake filled with chocolate buttercream. Frosted in chocolate buttercream. Topped with coconut pecan filling.
Creme De Mint
Layers of moist chocolate cake filled with mint custard. Frosted in chocolate buttercream. Garnished with Andes mints and chocolate drizzle.
Strawberries and Cream
Layers of fresh strawberry cake filled with vanilla custard. Frosted in homemade whipped cream. Garnished with fresh strawberry slices.
Cherry Chip
Layers of moist cherry chip cake filled with vanilla custard. Frosted in white buttercream frosting. Garnished with maraschino cherries.
Carrot
Layers of fresh carrot cake with pecans. Frosted in whipped cream cheese frosting. Garnished with pecans.
We accept cash, card, or Venmo as payment. No personal checks. Need a gift card?! Click here